← Back to the calculator

Is life insurance through work enough?

Short answer: for anyone with a mortgage or kids, no. Employer-paid basic group life is typically one times salary — a number set by your benefits department, not by your family's obligations. Supplemental group coverage can raise it, but it stays tied to the job, and its age-banded rates climb every five years until a healthy applicant is paying more than an individual term policy would cost.

Take the free coverage. Just do not confuse it with a plan.

This guide covers workplace coverage specifically. For the sizing method behind the numbers below, see how much life insurance you need, or use the calculator for your own figure.

Basic vs supplemental group life

Two different products arrive in the same benefits packet.

Basic group life is paid for by your employer, usually with no medical questions. Common amounts are one times salary or a flat sum such as $25,000 or $50,000. It costs you nothing, so there is no reason to decline it.

Supplemental group life is coverage you buy through payroll, typically in multiples of salary up to a plan maximum. During your initial enrollment window there is often a guaranteed issue amount you can take with no health questions at all. Above that, you complete evidence of insurability and get underwritten like any other applicant.

That guaranteed issue window is the genuinely valuable part of the benefit, and it is the part people most often skip. If you have a health condition that makes individual term expensive or unavailable, supplemental group life bought at open enrollment may be the best coverage you can get at any price.

One times salary against an actual need

The gap is easiest to see in numbers. Take someone earning $80,000, with a mortgage, two kids, and one times salary in basic coverage:

Component Amount
Mortgage balance $310,000
Other debt $22,000
Income replacement, ten years $800,000
Education, two children $100,000
Total need $1,232,000
Basic group life at one times salary $80,000
Shortfall $1,152,000

Basic coverage here handles about 6% of the need. Even stacking three times salary in supplemental coverage on top leaves the family more than $900,000 short.

The structural issue is the same one behind every employer benefit: the amount is indexed to payroll, and your family's need is indexed to debt and dependents.

The $50,000 rule nobody explains

Employer-paid group term life above $50,000 is not free after all. Under Section 79 of the tax code, the cost of employer-paid coverage over that threshold is treated as imputed income — a taxable amount added to your W-2 even though no money changed hands.

The amount is calculated from an IRS table based on your age, not from what your employer actually pays, and the rate per $1,000 of coverage rises steeply in the older brackets. In practice:

  • Coverage up to $50,000 is genuinely tax-free to you.
  • Above that, you pay income and payroll tax on a notional cost that grows as you age.
  • The death benefit itself remains income-tax-free to your beneficiary either way.

This is usually a modest line item, not a reason to decline coverage. It is worth knowing because it explains a mysterious entry on your pay stub, and because it means a large employer-paid benefit is not quite the free lunch it looks like at 55.

It ends when the job ends

Group life is not portable in any meaningful sense. Quit, get laid off, go independent, or retire, and the coverage stops — often at the end of that month.

Plans generally offer two exits, both with short deadlines measured in weeks:

Conversion turns the group coverage into an individual permanent policy with no health questions. It is valuable if you are uninsurable, and expensive otherwise — permanent coverage costs several times what term does.

Portability lets you keep term coverage by paying the insurer directly, usually at rates well above the group price and often with an age cutoff.

Both are worth knowing about precisely because they are the fallback when your health has changed. For a healthy person leaving a job, neither beats simply buying individual term — which is the argument for buying it before you need it.

Age bands, and when group coverage stops being cheap

Supplemental group rates are quoted per $1,000 of coverage and reset in five-year age bands. Your premium is flat for a while, then jumps on your next birthday inside a new band, then jumps again.

Individual level term does the opposite: the rate is locked at issue and stays there for the whole term. Someone who buys a 30-year policy at 32 pays that same premium at 55.

The crossover is real and it arrives sooner than most people expect. Group supplemental coverage is often the cheaper option in your twenties and early thirties, especially for smokers and people with health history, because the rate is blended across the whole workforce. For a healthy nonsmoker, individual term usually wins by the late thirties or forties, and the gap widens every band after that.

Two things to check today

Your beneficiary designation. The one on your group policy is separate from the one on your individual policy, and it is separate from your will. It also does not update itself after a divorce, a marriage or a new child. The beneficiary form controls the money — it passes outside probate, directly to whoever is named — so a stale designation is not a paperwork problem, it is a payout going to the wrong person.

Spouse and child riders. Many plans let you add small amounts on a spouse or children, often $10,000 to $25,000. These are inexpensive and fine as far as they go, but a $10,000 rider on a spouse who provides childcare, income or both is not coverage in any real sense. If your spouse would need to be replaced financially, they need a policy of their own.

What to do with it

  • Take the free basic coverage. It costs nothing.
  • Use guaranteed issue if your health is a problem. At open enrollment it may be the only coverage available to you without underwriting.
  • Price individual term against supplemental. If you are healthy and past your mid-thirties, run both numbers before electing multiples of salary through payroll.
  • Put the obligations that outlast the job in an individual policy. The mortgage does not end when the paycheck does.
  • Update the beneficiary form after any change in your family.

How to use the calculator

The calculator sizes your total need from your mortgage, other debt, income and children using the DIME method. Work out that number first, then subtract what your employer actually provides — the difference is what an individual policy needs to cover, and what you are exposed to the day you change jobs.

Try the calculator here, and see what coverage costs by age to compare against your payroll deduction.

Frequently asked questions